Xylem and Phloem are two specialised tissues that play a crucial role in the circulatory system of plants. The Xylem tissue is responsible for transporting water and nutrients from the roots to the different parts of the plant, while the Phloem tissue transports sugars and other organic molecules from the leaves to the different regions of the plant. In this article, we will look at the significant differences between Xylem and Phloem exploring their structural characteristics, functions, compositions, flow directions, locations, transport mechanisms, rates of movement, responses to injury, fibres, distribution patterns, movements, components and respective roles within the plant.
Table of Contents
Difference Between Xylem and Phloem – Tabular Format
| Factors | Xylem | Phloem |
|---|---|---|
| Definition | Specialised tissue that transports water and nutrients from roots to the rest of the plant | Specialised tissue that transports sugars and organic molecules from leaves to the rest of the plant |
| Function | Transports water and minerals | Transports sugars produced by photosynthesis |
| Composition | Composed of dead cells | Composed of living cells |
| Direction of Flow | Moves in upward direction | Moves bidirectionally (up and down) |
| Types of Cells | Tracheids, Vessel Elements, Fibres, Parenchyma cells | Sieve Tube Elements, Companion Cells, Fibres, Parenchyma cells |
| Location | Center of the plant stem | Outer side of the plant stem, beneath the bark |
| Transport Mechanism | Passive transport mechanism | Active transport mechanism |
| Movement Rate | Slower movement rate | Faster movement rate |
| Response to Injury | Forms scar tissue to seal wounds | Regenerates to bridge gaps |
| Fibres | Smaller fibres | Larger fibres |
| Found in | Roots, stems, and leaves | Stems and leaves |
| Movements | Unidirectional (moves upward) | Bidirectional (moves up and down) |
| Comprises | Hollow dead cells, Tracheids, Vessel Elements, Xylem Parenchyma, Xylem sclerenchyma, Xylem Fibres | Cytoplasm without nucleus, Companion Cells, Sieve tubes, Bast Fibres, Phloem Fibres, intermediary cells, and the Phloem Parenchyma |
| Provides | Mechanical strength to the plant | Translocates synthesized sugars to storage organs |
| Responsible for | Replacing lost water molecules through Transpiration and photosynthesis | Transporting proteins and mRNAs throughout the plant |
Difference Between Xylem and Phloem – Explained in Details
Difference Between Xylem and Phloem in terms of Definition
Xylem– Xylem is a specialised plant tissue responsible for transporting water and nutrients from the roots to the rest of the plant. It is composed of hollow, tube-like structures called tracheids and vascular elements. These structures are reinforced by a tough material called lignin, which gives strength and support to the Xylem tissue.
Phloem- Phloem is a specialised tissue in plants that transports sugars and other organic molecules from the leaves to the rest of the plant. It is composed of living cells called sieve elements and companion cells. The sieve elements are interconnected by sieve plates and form a continuous network for the flow of nutrients.
Also Check – Xylem – Definition , Structure, Components (Types), Functions And Importance
Difference Between Xylem and Phloem in terms of Function
Xylem- The main function of the Xylem is to transport water and minerals from the roots to the other parts of the plant. It provides moisture to the plant and supplies essential nutrients needed for growth, photosynthesis and other metabolic processes.
Phloem- The Phloem transports the sugars produced during photosynthesis from the leaves to the rest of the plant. These sugars, along with other organic molecules such as amino acids, hormones and signalling molecules, provide energy and nutrients for growth, storage and various metabolic processes throughout the plant.
Difference Between Xylem and Phloem in terms of Composition
Xylem- Xylem is composed of dead cells. The main cell types found in the Xylem include tracheids, vascular elements, fibres and parenchyma cells. Tracheids and vascular elements are responsible for water and mineral transport, while fibres provide mechanical strength and support. Parenchyma cells store nutrients and help with lateral transport within the Xylem tissue.
Phloem- The Phloem is composed of living cells. The main cell types in the Phloem tissue include sieve tube elements, companion cells, fibres and parenchyma cells. The sieve tube elements are responsible for transporting sugars and other organic molecules. Companion cells support the sieve elements in metabolism. The fibres contribute to the structural support of the Phloem tissue, and the parenchyma cells shop nutrients and help with lateral transport.
Also Check – Comparison of phloem and xylem hydraulic architecture in Picea abies stems
Difference Between Xylem and Phloem in terms of Direction of Flow
Xylem- The Xylem transports water and minerals in an upward direction, from the roots to the upper parts of the plant. This movement is driven by transpiration and the cohesive properties of water, which create a pulling force known as the transpiration pull.
Phloem- The Phloem moves in both directions, up and down, to distribute sugars and other organic molecules throughout the plant. This bidirectional flow allows the plant to efficiently distribute resources and transport sugars to growing tissues, storage organs and other parts of the plant.
Difference Between Xylem and Phloem in terms of Types of Cells
Xylem- The Xylem tissue consists of different types of cells. Tracheids and vascular elements are responsible for water and mineral transport. Fibres provide structural support, while parenchyma cells play a role in nutrient storage and lateral transport within the Xylem tissue.
Phloem- The Phloem tissue also contains various cell types. Sieve tube elements are specialised cells responsible for the transport of sugars and other organic molecules. Companion cells are closely associated with the sieve tube elements and provide metabolic support. Fibres contribute to the structural strength of the Phloem tissue, and parenchyma cells store nutrients and support lateral transport.
Also Check – Functions of the Xylem and Phloem
Difference Between Xylem and Phloem in terms of Location
Xylem- The Xylem tissue is located in the centre of the plant stem and forms a central column. It extends from the roots to the shoots and branches and ensures the transport of water and minerals throughout the plant.
Phloem- The Phloem tissue is located on the outer side of the plant stem, just below the bark. It forms a layer surrounding the Xylem and is responsible for distributing sugars and organic molecules to the different parts of the plant.
Also Check – How is Food Transported in Plants
Difference Between Xylem and Phloem in terms of Transport Mechanism
Xylem- The Xylem uses a passive transport mechanism to carry water and minerals. Water is drawn upwards by capillary action and transpiration. Transpiration, the loss of water vapour through the stomata in the leaves, creates a negative pressure that draws water upwards from the roots.
Phloem- The Phloem relies on an active transport mechanism to carry sugars and other organic molecules. This mechanism requires energy in the form of ATP (adenosine triphosphate). The sugars are actively loaded into the sieve tube elements in the source regions (e.g. leaves) and then transported to the sink regions (e.g. growing tissues or storage organs) by a process called translocation.
Difference Between Xylem and Phloem in terms of Movement Rate
Xylem- The Xylem moves at a relatively slow rate due to its passive transport mechanism. The movement of water and minerals through the Xylem tissue is driven by physical forces such as capillary action and transpiration pull. Therefore, the rate of movement is gradual but constant.
Phloem- The Phloem has a faster rate of movement, made possible by the active transport mechanism. The sugars and organic molecules in the Phloem sap are actively loaded into the sieve tube elements and pushed through the Phloem tissue by the osmotic pressure. This active transport enables relatively rapid movement of nutrients through the plant.
Also Check – What are the Differences between the Transport of Materials in Xylem and Phloem
Difference Between Xylem and Phloem in terms of Response to Injury
Xylem- When Xylem tissue is injured, it forms scar tissue to seal wounds and prevent excessive water loss. The formation of scar tissue helps to maintain the integrity of the Xylem and ensure the continuous transport of water and nutrients.
Phloem- In response to injury, Phloem tissue has the ability to regenerate and bridge gaps. This regenerative capacity allows the restoration of continuity of nutrient transport within the Phloem tissue.
Difference Between Xylem and Phloem in terms of Fibres
Xylem- The Xylem tissue contains smaller fibres that contribute to the mechanical strength of the plant and the strengthening of the stem. These fibres, together with other structural elements such as tracheids and vascular elements, provide support and rigidity to the plant’s vascular system.
Phloem- The Phloem tissue contains larger fibres that provide structural support to the Phloem tissue itself. These fibres improve the strength and stability of the Phloem and ensure the efficient transport of sugars and other organic molecules.
Difference Between Xylem and Phloem in terms of Distribution
Xylem- The Xylem tissue is found in roots, stems and leaves and ensures the transport of water and nutrients throughout the plant. It forms a continuous network that connects all parts of the plant and enables the distribution of key resources.
Phloem- The Phloem tissue is mainly found in the stems and leaves. It is responsible for distributing sugars and organic molecules produced by photosynthesis to various parts of the plant, including growing tissues, storage organs (such as roots, bulbs and tubers) and other areas where these nutrients are needed.
Also Check – Phloem – Definition, Structure, Function, Types and How does Phloem tissue work
Difference Between Xylem and Phloem in terms of Movements
Xylem- Xylem exhibits unidirectional movement, primarily transporting water and nutrients upwards from the roots to the upper parts of the plant. This upward movement is crucial for supplying water and minerals to the leaves and other aerial parts of the plant.
Phloem- The Phloem has a bidirectional movement that allows the distribution of sugars and organic molecules both upwards and downwards. This bidirectional flow allows efficient allocation of resources to the various plant tissues and organs according to their requirements.
Also Check – What is Root Pressure ?
Difference Between Xylem and Phloem in terms of Components
Xylem- Xylem tissue is made up of various components, including hollow, dead cells. These include tracheids and vascular elements involved in water and mineral transport. Xylem also contains Xylem parenchyma cells that aid in lateral transport, as well as Xylem sclerenchyma cells and Xylem fibres that provide mechanical strength and support.
Phloem- Phloem tissue is composed of living cells without nuclei. It includes companion cells which provide metabolic support the sieve tube elements in metabolism. The most important conducting cells in the Phloem are the sieve tube elements, which are interconnected and responsible for sugar transport. The Phloem also contains bast fibres, Phloem fibres, intermediate cells and Phloem parenchyma cells.
Difference Between Xylem and Phloem in terms of Role
Xylem- Xylem tissue plays an important role in the mechanical strength of the plant and contributes to the overall structural support, especially in the stem. The rigidity and strength of the Xylem cells help the plant stand upright and support the weight of the leaves and reproductive structures.
Phloem- Phloem tissue is primarily responsible for transporting synthesised sugars from the photosynthetic areas of the plants (such as the leaves) to the storage organs such as roots, bulbs and tubers. By facilitating the transport of sugars, the Phloem ensures a constant supply of energy to the various parts of the plant.
Difference Between Xylem and Phloem in terms of Responsibilities
Xylem- In addition to transporting water and minerals, the Xylem tissue is also responsible for replacing water molecules lost through transpiration. The Xylem also contributes to the movement of proteins and mRNA molecules throughout the plant, enabling systemic communication and coordination.
Phloem- Phloem is primarily responsible for the transport of proteins and mRNA molecules throughout the plant. This systemic distribution of vital substances within the plant is essential for various physiological processes, including growth, development and defence mechanisms.
Curious Questions on Xylem And Phloem
Can xylem and phloem cells repair themselves if damaged?
- Xylem cannot repair itself once damaged as it is made of dead cells. Phloem can regenerate to some extent because it’s composed of living cells.
Why can’t xylem transport sugars like phloem does?
- Xylem is specialised for transporting water and minerals, not sugars. Its structure and mechanism are suited for upward water movement, not for distributing organic compounds.
Do all plants have both xylem and phloem?
- Yes, all vascular plants have both xylem and phloem. They are essential for transporting water, nutrients, and sugars throughout the plant.
How fast do xylem and phloem transport substances?
- Xylem transports water at a slower rate due to its reliance on transpiration pull. Phloem transport is faster as it uses active transport and pressure flow.
What would happen if a plant’s xylem was blocked?
- Blocking the xylem would stop water transport, leading to wilting, nutrient deficiency, and potentially the plant’s death.
Can xylem transport water downwards?
- No, xylem primarily moves water upwards. Downward movement of water is not a function of the xylem.
Why don’t xylem cells have nuclei?
- Xylem cells are dead at maturity, so they do not need nuclei. Their primary function is to form tubes for water transport.
How does phloem know where to transport sugars?
- Phloem distributes sugars based on the plant’s needs. Areas of high sugar concentration (sources) transport sugars to areas of low concentration (sinks) like roots or fruits.
Can humans use xylem or phloem in any way?
- Indirectly, yes. Wood, used in construction and paper, is primarily composed of xylem. Phloem is essential for the growth of fruits and other plant parts that we consume.
Why is xylem located in the centre of the stem, and phloem on the outside?
- This arrangement allows xylem to provide structural support and makes it easier for phloem to distribute sugars to the outer parts of the plant.
Does the amount of xylem or phloem change as a plant grows?
- Yes, as plants grow, they develop more xylem and phloem to support increased water, nutrient, and sugar transport needs.
Can xylem and phloem cells change their function?
- No, xylem and phloem cells are specialised and cannot change their function once differentiated.
Do xylem and phloem work together?
- They work independently but are interconnected in their roles, supporting the plant’s overall nutrition and health.
What happens to xylem and phloem in the winter?
- In many plants, xylem and phloem activities slow down due to reduced temperatures and transpiration rates.
Are there any diseases that specifically target xylem or phloem?
- Yes, some diseases and pests target xylem or phloem. For example, Dutch elm disease affects the xylem of elm trees.
How do plants control the flow in xylem and phloem?
- Plants control xylem flow through root pressure, transpiration pull, and stomatal opening. Phloem flow is regulated by sugar concentration and active transport mechanisms.
Can the same cell be part of both xylem and phloem?
- No, a cell can either be part of xylem or phloem, not both, due to their distinct structures and functions.
Frequently asked Questions on Difference Between Xylem and Phloem
Question- Which type of plant tissue transports water and nutrients from the roots to the rest of the plant?
Answer- Xylem.
Question- What gives strength and support to the xylem tissue?
Answer- Lignin.
Question- Which type of plant tissue transports sugars and other organic molecules from the leaves to the rest of the plant?
Answer- Phloem.
Also Check – What are the Components of Transport System in Highly Organised Plants
Question- What are the main cell types found in xylem tissue?
Answer- Tracheids, vascular elements, fibres, and parenchyma cells.
Question- Which type of cells in phloem tissue are responsible for transporting sugars and other organic molecules?
Answer- Sieve tube elements.
Question- Does xylem transport water and minerals in an upward or downward direction?
Answer- Upward direction.
Question- Does phloem transport sugars and other organic molecules in a unidirectional or bidirectional flow?
Answer- Bidirectional flow.
Question- Where is xylem tissue located in the plant stem?
Answer- In the centre of the plant stem, forming a central column.
Question- Where is phloem tissue located in the plant stem?
Answer- On the outer side of the plant stem, just below the bark.
Question- Does xylem use a passive or active transport mechanism?
Answer- Xylem uses a passive transport mechanism.
Question- Does phloem use a passive or active transport mechanism?
Answer- Phloem uses an active transport mechanism.
Question- What is the driving force behind the upward movement of water in xylem tissue?
Answer- Transpiration pull.
Question- Which type of plant tissue contains living cells?
Answer- Phloem.
Question- Which type of plant tissue contains dead cells?
Answer- Xylem.
Question- What is the main function of xylem tissue?
Answer- Transporting water and minerals.
Question- What is the main function of phloem tissue?
Answer- Transporting sugars and other organic molecules.
Question- Which tissue, xylem or phloem, has a faster rate of movement?
Answer- Phloem.
Question- How does water and mineral transport occur in xylem tissue?
Answer- Through physical forces such as capillary action and transpiration pull.
Question- What is the driving force behind the movement of sugars in phloem tissue?
Answer- Osmotic pressure.
Question- How does xylem tissue respond to injury?
Answer- It forms scar tissue to seal wounds and prevent excessive water loss.
Question- What is the regenerative capacity of phloem tissue in response to injury?
Answer- It can regenerate and bridge gaps to restore continuity of nutrient transport.
Question- In terms of fibres, which tissue contains smaller fibers: xylem or phloem?
Answer- Xylem.
Question- How do fibres contribute to the xylem tissue?
Answer- They provide mechanical strength and support to the plant.
Question- What is the main location of phloem tissue within the plant?
Answer- Mainly in the stems and leaves.
Question- Apart from distributing sugars, where else does phloem transport organic molecules?
Answer- Growing tissues, storage organs, and other areas where these nutrients are needed.
Question- What is the movement direction of xylem tissue?
Answer- Upward, from the roots to the upper parts of the plant.
Question- Does phloem exhibit unidirectional or bidirectional movement?
Answer- Bidirectional movement.
Question- What are the main components of xylem tissue?
Answer- Tracheids, vascular elements, fibres, and parenchyma cells.
Question- Which type of cells are responsible for sugar transport in the phloem?
Answer- Sieve tube elements.
Question- What is the role of xylem tissue in the plant?
Answer– It contributes to the mechanical strength and structural support of the plant.
Question- What is the primary role of phloem tissue in the plant?
Answer- Transporting synthesised sugars from photosynthetic areas to storage organs.
Question- Apart from sugars, what else does phloem transport throughout the plant?Answer- Proteins and mRNA molecules.
2 Comments on “15 Difference between Xylem and Phloem”